A mutual fund is a financial vehicle composed of a pool of funds collected from many investors for the purpose of investing in securities like stocks, bonds, money market instruments, and other assets, managed by Asset Management Companies (AMCs). Mutual fund’s aim to produce capital gains and income for the fund’s investors. Mutual funds allow individual investors access to diversified, professionally managed portfolios at a relatively low cost. It is an ideal option for those who seek to diversify their investments without the need to manage and monitor a large portfolio of individual securities.
Here are the Advantages and Disadvantages of mutual funds to assist you in making a well-informed choice.
The Advantages of Mutual Funds
Liquidity
Mutual funds offer high liquidity, allowing investors to buy or sell units easily during market hours at the current NAV, with some exceptions like ELSS which have lock-in periods. Investors should consider exit loads and expense ratios, which may impact returns, but overall, mutual funds provide a flexible and accessible investment option compared to fixed deposits.
Diversification
Diversification in mutual funds is a strategic approach to spread investments across various stocks from different industries and sectors, minimizing risk. This method ensures that even if one asset class underperforms, others can offset the losses, thereby protecting investor gains. It serves as a crucial advantage, reducing the overall risk for investors by including multiple securities within a single investment portfolio. Essentially, mutual funds’ diversification allows for a more stable and less volatile investment experience by balancing potential losses with gains from other sectors.
Professional Management:
Mutual funds are managed by expert fund managers who handle investment selection and strategy, making them ideal for investors without the time or expertise for direct market engagement. These professionals assess and allocate funds across various securities, guided by each fund’s objectives and regulatory limits on expense ratios (max 2.25% annually). Investors benefit from their experience in maximizing returns and navigating market dynamics, offering a hands-off investment approach through diversified, professionally managed portfolios.
Flexibility
Mutual funds provide the convenience of investing with small amounts, offering flexibility for those with varying income levels and cash flows. Through Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), investors can contribute fixed amounts regularly, making it suitable for monthly earners. Accessible worldwide via demat or mutual fund accounts, investments in mutual funds can be made easily online, allowing investors to manage their portfolios in one place.
Safety and Transparency
Mutual funds use a SEBI-mandated color-coding system to signal risk levels, debunking myths about their safety compared to bank products. They’re under strict regulation by bodies like SEBI and AMFI, ensuring transparency and investor protection. Details such as performance, fund manager credentials, and daily NAV are readily available, supporting informed investment decisions.
Tax Inefficiency
Mutual funds offer tax benefits, especially through ELSS (Equity-Linked Savings Scheme) funds, which allow for a tax deduction of up to Rs. 1.5 lakh annually under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act. While ELSS funds are subject to a 10% tax on Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) exceeding Rs 1 lakh, they typically yield higher returns compared to other tax-saving options like FDs, NPS, and PPF, providing a dual advantage of tax savings and potential for greater returns.
Disadvantages of Mutual Funds
Costs of managing
The salaries of market analysts and fund managers, along with the operational costs of a mutual fund, are borne by the investors. It’s crucial to consider total fund management charges when selecting a mutual fund, as higher fees don’t guarantee superior performance. Despite the potential benefits of mutual funds, high fees can be a significant drawback. In India, for instance, some mutual funds come with hefty costs. Exiting a fund before a specified period may also result in additional charges, and withdrawing funds prematurely is often not permitted.
Entry or Exit Load
Mutual funds may impose entry or exit loads, up to 3% but typically around 1%, to cover operational costs and staff salaries. While these fees can impact profits, funds with higher loads often yield superior returns. Exit loads, acting as a deterrent to early withdrawals, help maintain fund stability and allow managers to invest effectively. However, they can discourage investment by reducing returns for those who exit within the lock-in period.
Liquidity issues
Liquidity issues in mutual funds, notably in fixed maturity plans (FMPs) and Equity-Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS), arise from mandated lock-in periods—three years for ELSS and varying for FMPs based on the maturity of underlying assets (e.g., a 5-year bond). These lock-in periods restrict immediate access to invested capital. Additionally, while mutual funds are often highlighted for their liquidity, various funds implement charges on early withdrawals, further discouraging investors from accessing their funds prematurely and impacting the overall liquidity advantage typically associated with mutual fund investments.
Tax Inefficiency
Capital gains from mutual funds are taxed, with short-term gains (withdrawn before one year) facing 15% to 20% tax, and long-term gains (after a year) taxed at 10%. Investors must also grasp indexation for accurate tax calculations. Additionally, mutual funds distribute capital gains, taxing shareholders even without selling shares, a notable issue in actively managed funds due to frequent trades. Taxation varies by dividend earnings, holding period, and whether gains are short-term or long-term, with different criteria for equity, debt, and hybrid funds, complicating the tax implications for investors.
Dilution
Dilution in mutual funds occurs when excessive diversification spreads investments too thinly across many assets, diminishing the influence of high-performing investments on the fund’s overall returns. This can result in average or subpar performance despite the presence of strong individual assets within the portfolio.
Lack of Control
Investors in mutual funds lack direct control over the fund’s investment decisions. While they can access the fund’s disclosure norms and Scheme Information Document (SID) for transparency, the ultimate authority on selecting specific stocks or securities rests solely with the fund manager. This arrangement means that the investment choices made may not align with the personal preferences or risk tolerance of individual investors, highlighting a trade-off between benefiting from professional management and relinquishing personal investment control.
Read more
Conclusion
Investing in mutual funds offers professional management and diversification but comes with fees, tax implications, and lack of control. While they can mitigate risk and simplify investing, it’s vital for investors to balance these advantages with potential drawbacks like costs and diluted returns. Success in mutual fund investing hinges on selecting funds that align with one’s financial goals and risk tolerance, considering fee structures and investment strategies. Proper evaluation helps maximize benefits and minimize disadvantages, making mutual funds a valuable part of a diversified investment portfolio.
